I saw Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire tonight. I can't believe everyone enjoyed it so much. It was an alright film, but there's far too many holes to pick with it than I can write, or can be bothered writing.
For one thing, what was with the lack of plot and character development? Things weren't explained, and the characters motives in situations weren't even touched on. One of the major omissions was the Snape and the Death Eaters storyline. For one thing, in the book, the sense of evil and suspicion permeates the story. Anyone around you could be a Death Eater, they were working inside the Ministry, Snape had been a Death Eater and was working inside Hogwarts. All this was underplayed, and the sense of impending doom and evil was lost. The Death Eaters were needed to show the the power of Voldemort, not just in that he had an secret police, but that these people, fearsome in themselves, cowered under the mere look of the Dark Lord.
I felt that the book truly portayed the evil, and the feeling of Voldemort's growing power, but in the film, the entire story was about the Triwizard Tournament, and Harry, Ron and Hemione's angsty teenage issues.
With the intense plot in the book, and super intense sub-plots, the film was a joke. To think the ENTIRE Barty Crouch Senior and Junior storyline was just abandoned. As was Moody's past. Why was he called insane? You don't find out. Cedric Diggory's death was undramatic, whereas in the actual story, it was a huge deal, and very heart wrenching. I could go so in depth into what this film was lacking, even as a film in it's own right it didn't answer so many of it's questions.
The Goblet of Fire is pivotal to the series, as it acts as the foundation of the books to come. The previous issues have been a prologue, they've been teaching you about the past and the characters, so you understand the real story still to come. The fourth in the series is the beginning of the story, and lays down the structure for the rest, and with it done in such a shallow way, I can't imagine how the next film will be redeemed.
The director was sadly lacking I found. He focused too much on the human issues, and not enough on the real plot. As such it came across as undeveloped and the tension wasn't built up in the slightest. My personal opinion is that he would fare better in a real life drama, not a fantasy film. I think if Peter Jackson had been directing, things would have turned out infinitely better. He has experience in adapting books to films, and does it amazingly well. He understands fantasy, and doesn't make it all about CGI, instead uses it to enhance the movie. I hope to god he is involved in The Order of the Phoenix. It would be perfect for him.
So much I haven't said, and I can't be bothered. I've bored you all enough anyway. Anyone's who's still reading this gets a hug.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

4 comments:
Wheee...I can't wait to see this now.
You shouldn't worry about the post being too long. Just look at a typical entry from my blog, then you'll know the feeling of falling asleep reading them...
i liked it.
considering they cut the book down to 2 and a half hours, it was alright.
obviously its going to be nothing like the book, and i feel it unfair to compare the movies to the book, but as a progression of the movie series its really good, although the first and second ones are the best, imo.
i know they cut a lot out, but could you imagine how long it would have been if they put it all in? they cut a 700 page book into and 2hrs 30mins, an achievement if ever there was one.
oh, and about the peter jackson thing, he's too busy doing the halo movie, plus he'd be shite at doing harry potter.
Peter Jackson would be brilliant with Harry Potter, and since we already had this discussion today I won't bring it up again except to say that they had the time to put the most important aspects of the story in, and they chose the wrong things, which could make it difficult for the next films to follow the book well.
I agree with you. At the end they missed out the ENTIRE Barty escaping from jail storyline. There was nothing about Winky either (Dunno whether this was good or bad :P, although with one of the boks having an anti-elf abuse club she should have been in it). It was still a great fim though. Is it just me or are most of them Irish in that movie.
Post a Comment